Toddler Adjusting to a New Sibling When Plans Fall Apart

“Can I give you a gentle hug?”

That was the first thing Madeline said when I walked back in the door at Kier’s house after my surgery. She’s three and a half. Before Henry came, I wrote about getting her ready for her baby brother, the room swap, the why questions, and the Pull-Ups back in the drawer. This is the other half of that story. It’s what a toddler adjusting to a new sibling looks like when almost none of the getting-ready stuff gets used.

The plan we had for Madeline

Henry’s due date was somewhere between September 29 and October 2. The plan was to have a few more weeks to ease Madeline in, the same way I’d been preparing a toddler for a new sibling since I got there, with a steady voice and an answer for every why. She had already moved into a new bedroom to make space for the nursery, and she took it well, mostly because the new room came with toys.

The plan had a second part. Once Henry was born, J and I were going to take Madeline back to our place for a couple of weeks. Kier and her husband would get time with their new baby. Madeline would get a change of scenery and get her Lolli to herself.

My mom did that for me when I had a new baby. I wanted to do it for my daughter.

None of it happened.

A hospital bed and a brother on a video

On September 22, Kier’s blood pressure ran high at her appointment, and by that afternoon the doctor was talking about inducing her. I had been the one with Madeline from morning to afternoon so the family didn’t have to pay for daycare. That day she went to daycare for a few hours anyway, because nobody had planned for any of this. I picked her up, made dinner for Kier, filled Madeline’s lunch bag, and drove her to the hospital to see her momma.

Her momma was in a hospital bed with a cuff on her arm. Madeline had a lot of questions for Doctor Kent and Nurse Tara. I don’t remember what she asked. I remember there were a lot of them, and they answered her.

Henry was born the next morning, and that afternoon they flew him to the NICU in Twin Falls. I wrote that day minute by minute, sharing what it was like being grandma in the delivery room. Madeline didn’t know anything about the helicopter.

Kier had to stay at the hospital where Henry was born. Her husband drove to Twin Falls to be with Henry. Madeline was home with J and me. That week our family was split across two hospitals and a house.

Two days later, she saw her baby brother for the first time on video.

That’s how a toddler adjusting to a new sibling met hers. No countdown. No hospital bag she helped pack. A screen.

Meeting Henry in the NICU

A big sister meeting her baby brother in the NICU for the first time. toddler adjusting to a new sibling

When Henry was four days old, I drove Madeline to Twin Falls to meet him in person.

Most of what’s written about a toddler adjusting to a new sibling in the NICU assumes there’s time to get the big sister ready first. Hand to Hold suggests describing the wires and monitors to a sibling before a NICU visit, so the room isn’t a surprise. We didn’t do any of that. There wasn’t time.

Her face was a bit confused when we walked in. A lot of medical equipment surrounded him. Her mom and dad were already there, so she went to them first and hugged them both.

Then she looked at Henry. She asked why he had tubes in his nose and stickers on his cheeks. We told her he needed help breathing.

She kissed him while her mom held him.

When her Lolli was the one at the doctor’s

A three-year-old holding her grandmother's hand while her grandmother recovers from surgery.

Henry came home on a Tuesday. Two days later, I was the one in the hospital.

I’ve written about it in its own post, so I’ll keep this part short. Early that Thursday morning, J drove me to the ER, and by 11:00 I was in surgery in Twin Falls, the same city they had flown Henry to. Madeline was told that Lolli wasn’t feeling good and was at the doctor. That was true. She didn’t know I went in a helicopter either.

So in a little over a week, her momma went to the hospital, then her brother, then her Lolli. For a toddler adjusting to new sibling changes, that’s a lot of grownups going away to the same kind of building.

Northwestern Medicine’s handout for NICU families talks about keeping familiar caregivers and routines in place for toddlers while a baby is in the hospital. I had been the familiar caregiver. For a while I wasn’t there, and when I came back, I couldn’t do most of what I used to.

When I walked back into Kier’s house, I couldn’t lift anything. I couldn’t pick up Henry or Madeline. I came in slowly. Madeline met me at the door and asked if she could give me a gentle hug.

I told her yes, but I wasn’t feeling well.

After that, she helped me when she could. A few times, she took my hand and walked me to the bathroom. She was helpful and gentle. Impressive for a three-year-old.

For weeks, she had followed me around the house asking why. Now she was the one leading me down the hall.

A toddler adjusting to a new sibling, the honest version

Some days Madeline loves Henry. Some days, not so much.

Before he was born, she told me she’d share with her baby brother. Now she holds his bottle. She thinks it’s funny when he pees on Momma in the middle of a diaper change.

Then there was dinner and bedtime. In our house, that’s where a toddler adjusting to a new sibling changes showed it most.

She wouldn’t eat dinner in a timely manner, and some nights she wouldn’t eat it at all. Bedtime turned into a few hours of screaming, excuses to come back downstairs, and playing around when she should have been in bed. She wasn’t falling asleep until 11:00.

It wasn’t like her.

UF Health says that gaining a new brother or sister can disrupt a child’s bedtime habits, and it can take time to get them back. For us, it was taking time. I’m not a doctor, and I can only tell you what a toddler adjusting to new sibling life looked like in this house. In this house, it looked like a three-year-old still awake at 11:00.

The night I climbed the stairs

I spent most of those bedtimes in my room, lying in bed. I was weeks out of surgery and still not allowed to lift anything. The back pain was the worst. I couldn’t lift her, and I couldn’t carry her back to bed. I could hear all of it.

A few weeks into my recovery, I had enough.

I got up and walked upstairs slowly. I disciplined Madeline and raised my voice.

She was upset. She fell asleep.

The next morning she came and apologized to me. She apologized to her mom too. I made sure she knew that acting that way was not okay. Then I told her thank you.

I felt bad that it came to that. But it was needed.

A lot of the advice out there on a toddler adjusting to new sibling changes says to meet the acting out with reassurance. I understand why. I’m still sure I did the right thing.

Was three really the hardest age?

In the first post, I said three to four is the hardest age for a toddler adjusting to a new sibling. Old enough to notice everything that’s changing. Not old enough to understand what her new role will be once the baby is here.

I still think that. It was rough, and it was not like her to act that way.

Madeline is the only grandchild on both sides of this family, and the only great-grandchild too. Before September, she had never shared any of us with another child. Then, all at once, she was sharing every one of us with Henry, and her Lolli was too sore to pick her up.

That’s a lot for a toddler adjusting to new sibling changes at any age. At three and a half, she noticed every bit of it. What any of it meant for her was another thing.

About five weeks after Henry came, after the night I climbed the stairs, Madeline’s other grandmother came into town and took her for four nights. When Madeline came back, things were much calmer.

A toddler adjusting to a new sibling sometimes needs time away. Madeline did. That was my plan from the start: a couple of weeks at our place with J and me, the way my mom did it for me. I still think things would have gone better if it had happened. Maybe they would have. I’ll never know.

If you’re a grandma watching a toddler adjusting to a new sibling change from close by, that’s the one thing I’d hold onto from all of this. Sometimes the older one needs a change of scenery.

Four nights weren’t the two weeks I planned. They still helped.

Madeline is Henry’s big sister. She’s the one who asked if she could give her Lolli a gentle hug.


If you’ve watched a toddler adjusting to a new sibling changes in your own family, what age did you find hardest? Did a few days away help? I’d like to hear about it in the comments. And if you subscribe, you’ll see what comes next for Madeline and Henry.


Leave a Comment